The same year, 1586, Salazar sent Fray John de Valenzuela to round up all the brethren wandering around Peru without benefit of patents from their religious superiors. It almost felt improper to hear them when they are forbidden to have any contact. Both orders follow the Rule of St Albert. There are significantly more OCD nuns than O.Carm. The Founding of the Discalced Carmelites A combination of political and social conditions that prevailed in Europe in the fourteenth to sixteenth centuries- the Hundred Years' War, Black Plague, the Protestant revolt and the Humanist revival - adversely affected the Order. We reside at Mt St. Joseph Carmelite Monastery in San Jose, California. Institute on Religious Life P.O. Still learning, but the O.carm charism are prayer, community and service. constitutions will be based off of the Constitutions that St Teresa of Avila wrote, she did not write a rule. I'm currently in third order formation with O. Carm. This has actually given rise to an inside joke in the wider carmelite family that you can no longer tell the carmelites apart by what they wear on their feet. After the footsteps of the Holy Parents, they are called to give witness to the prophetic spirit of the first Carmelites. at the time of St Teresa’s death and then was a reformed province at the time of St John’s death. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If you can get hold of this book: Climbing the Mountain, The Carmelite Journey, I highly recommend it. In your own time you are welcome to… explore, enjoy, be enriched and challenged by this gift of the Spirit Breath of Life “Prayer belongs to all: To people of all […] I am a secular discalced carmelite and have a lot of experience with the O. Carms and the Discalced. Both orders follow the Rule of St Albert. Thank you …one last question, do the O.Carm nuns vary their habit too from the OCD? The British Province also extends its condolences to our Discalced brethren following the deaths of two members of the Anglo-Irish Province. nuns in Wahpeton, ND. But please don’t take my enthusiasm as a downplay of the O.Carm who are equally to be esteemed. Carmelite Institute of Britain and Ireland. They did not become an order of their own until about a year after the death of St John. Thanks in advance. The difference isn’t much. The differences between the two orders seems to be largely historical. Here is the Sister’s picture. is the Order of teh Brothers of the Blessed Virgin Mary of Mount Carmel. Most canonized Carmelite Saints are OCD as well. These days you are just as likely to find a discalced nun without a habit as you are an o. Carms friar with sandals and a strict observance if the rule. We were founded by Mother Angeline Teresa, O.Carm in 1929. Many O.Carm.s wear sandals and some O.C.D.s wear shoes. Our ministry is taking care of the Aged and Infirm in a nursing home setting. St. Theresa Theresa or Thérèse, Saint (Theresa of Lisieux), 1873–97, French Carmelite nun, one of the most widely loved saints of the Roman Catholic Church, b. Alençon. First, the shoe thing isn’t really that much of a difference any more. These two branches of Carmel however have very close ties and the Rule of the one is fully appreciated by the other and both branches (including their saints) form the overall Carmelite family - to my understanding. Some are thriving, just as with the Poor Clares; others are not. constitutions will be based off of the Constitutions that St Teresa of Avila wrote, she did not write a rule. I’d heard that this Monastery was losing Nuns. They are strictly cloistered and seem to be much more severe than any Carmelite friars at least in the US. For official apologetics resources please visit, Carmelites: Discalced vs. The Carmalite friars can count to more than 10 without taking their socks off =D, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the Catholicism community. Now, thanks to a generous benefactor, the twelve Carmelites will have a permanent home (see complete story). Our (O.Carm.) Many O.Carm.s wear sandals and some O.C.D.s wear shoes. The Discalced Carmelite Monastery of Divine Mercy and Our Lady of Guadalupe, Brooklyn. She gave me a prayer from St. Therese that she used to pray for priests. The website for Secular Order Discalced Carmelites living in the England, Wales and Scotland. The Discalced Carmelites, known officially as the Order of the Discalced Carmelites of the Blessed Virgin Mary of Mount Carmel or the Order of Discalced Carmelites, is a Catholic mendicant order with roots in the eremitic tradition of the Desert Fathers and Mothers. Visit the page. I think discalced Carmelites are a little stricter. scapular is a bit longer as is our capuche and we have a full hood. Carmelite Spirit Carmelite Spirituality has inspired and helped people to a deeper life. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. The women’s branch of the Order began in 1452, and a century later St. Teresa of Avila initiated her reform which spread throughout the world and became known as the Discalced Carmelites. I belong to the Order of Carmelites (O.Carm) Congregation called the Carmelite Sisters for the Aged and Infirm. The Teresian Carmelites today are challenged to live their great tradition of contemplative prayer and apostolic service to the Church. The Discalced Carmelites are a Roman Catholic religious community of priests, brothers, nuns, and laity serving the Church through lives of prayer and ministry, in a fraternal setting. THE CARMELITE FAMILY: CARMELITE PROVINCES | CARMELITE NUNS | CARMELITE HERMIT COMMUNITIES | LAY CARMELITES | AFFILIATED CONGREGATIONS AND INSTITUTES. I don’t know much about O.Carm at all really that I can recall, except reading O.Carm articles, and am presupposing that there are O.Carm nuns?..Barb:). The Discalced Carmelites cultivate the contemplative life in all aspects, and they have produced many works on mystical theology. one time. From what I have read, the austerity of Discalced Carmelites is noticeably different from that of the ordinary Carmelites. She was so sweet, too. www.sanjosecarmelites.com Emir reformu uyarınca 1593 yılında kurulmuş Antik Observance Karmelit Order iki tarafından İspanyol aziz, Aziz Ávila'nın Teresa ve Aziz Haç John. As in terms of how this affects their ministries, with O. Carm, they mainly do parishes and retreats, while OCD friars will mainly stay in the friary, occasionaly you'll find an OCD parish or college professor. I pray it’s not the case, but I wonder how the Carmelites (both Discalced and Ancient Observance) as a whole are doing? They are a fairly new diocesan community. Ben, if you’re referring to the nuns, that is hard to say, because while the nuns’ monasteries in both O.Carm. /r/Catholicism is a place to present new developments in the world of Catholicism, discuss theological teachings of the Catholic Church, provide an avenue for reasonable dialogue amongst people of all beliefs, and grow in our own spirituality. religiouslife.com irlstaff@religiouslife.com (847) 573-8975 . The difference isn’t much. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Accordingly Discalced Carmelites advented to our country in the beginning of the seventeenth century, and founded their first residence at Tattan in Sind (Pakistan) and second in Goa in 1620. We are part of the Discalced Carmelite Friars California-Arizona Province of St Joseph. The Discalced Carmelites are a Roman Catholic religious community of priests, brothers, nuns, and laity serving the Church through lives of prayer and ministry, in a fraternal setting. On this site we seek to share that spirituality with you. The missionary activities of the Carmelites extended to the Southern most part … are a bit more active. They also use traditional liturgy and Gregorian chant. Carmelite Chronicles: The Missions and the Discalced Carmelites. The Carmelite Institute of Britain and Ireland (CIBI) is a collaborative initiative of the British and Irish Provinces of Carmelites and the Anglo-Irish Province of Discalced Carmelites. Would you happen to know of a site where I could see an O.Carm habit? “Today is a great day, a great gift from God,” said Discalced Carmelite Sister Angela Pikus, of the Danville community. This house is the Novitiate for the Province. Nuns and the Discalced Reform In 1535 Teresa Sánchez de Cepeda y Ahumada - better known to us as Saint Teresa of Jesus - entered 'The Incarnation' in Avila, Spain. Our roots that go back to twelfth-century hermits on Mount Carmel in the Holy Land. : O.C.D. It's given me some hope that once the younger generations are in charge the orders will finally merge. Ancient Observance. Box 7500 Libertyville, IL 60048. Home web page for the Discalced Carmelite Friars of San Jose. My opinion only! Does someone know how many Carmelites are cloistered and how many work in public ministries? Hey, those two Saints are great enough to share. I do not know enough about the women’s groups to answer this, sorry. The Discalced Carmelites also faced much opposition from other unreformed Carmelite houses (notably, Carmelites from Toledo arrested and imprisoned John of the Cross in their own monastery). They have like 7 or 8 in the novitiate. I believe that the O.Carm. Our (O.Carm.) There are a couple of members far more informed on the Carmelite Order than I am, but to my understanding the O.Carm’s follow the Ancient Rule of St. Albert which was the original Carmelite Rule, while the OCD (discalced) follow the Rule of St. Teresa of Avila, which was revised by Vatican2. I believe that the O.Carm. Besides not wearing shoes, what are the differences between Discalced Carmelites and the regular Carmelites (Carmelites of the Ancient Observance)? Highlights. Discalced Carmelites observe a stricter lifestyle and rule. The O.C.D. We are an enclosed, contemplative community of nuns in Goonellabah, New South Wales, Australia, whose lives are dedicated to prayer for the needs of the Church and the whole world. It was beautiful, but also a little strange. That's primarily true of what you might call the Vatican 2 generation. MULTIFORMIS SAPIENTIA DEI | 50th of the Teresian doctorate. They are more enclosed(when compared to ordinary Carmelites) and put a larger emphasis on personal austerity(they don't wear shoes much, if it all, and have a much more regimented day and prayer). They are more enclosed(when compared to ordinary Carmelites) and put a larger emphasis on personal austerity(they don't wear shoes much, if it all, and have a much more regimented day and prayer). Prepare yourself for Christmas together with the Discalced Carmelites. Only in the 1580s did the Discalced Carmelites gain official approval of their status. was just a reform movement within the O.Carm. The Incarnation was a beguinage of women who had undertaken varying levels of religious commitment within the Carmelite Order. Cloistered Life Forum. He entered the Order of Discalced Carmelites in Loughrea in 1959 and made his First Profession there on September 8, 1960. Their congregation is called the Carmel of Mary, and they belong to the O.Carm. or Carmelites of the Ancient Observance. The Mass and blessing were attended by a number of faithful from the diocese, including several Discalced Carmelites from Danville, who lived at the monastery from 1961 until their move to Danville in 2008. The OCD friars tend to be a bit stricter and have more of a contemplative focus than the O.Carm friars. Father John McNamara, O.C.D. Discalced Carmelites of Goonellabah. The Discalced Carmelite Friars of the Oklahoma Province of St. Thérèse are a community of Roman Catholic men – priests and religious brothers – committed to a life of allegiance to Jesus Christ. Discalced Carmelites of Brooklyn. This is especially true of the African and American provinces. (1938-2020) was a priest of Glasgow Archdiocese before joining the Discalced Carmelites in 1990, serving in Loughrea, Kensington, St. Teresa's in Dublin, and Derry. And, of course, I want to boast the excellence of the Discalced Carmelites - since I am a Discalced Carmelite at heart (it is very probable that I will become O.C.D.S in the future :gopray: ). I am discerning my vocation to religious life, and I would like to learn more about the Carmelite Orders, but I am having difficulty pin pointing in the modern age the differences between the two in terms of charism and practices (especially also since both Orders share each others' Saints and their spiritualities). View my public profile and you will see me in my habit from the waist up. Just one more side note, the official name of the O.Carm. Yeah, I would say that the Discalced Carmelites are more contemplative. This was when she was a postulant, but when I met her, she was in the habit with a black veil (temporary professed): http://www.fargodiocese.org/vocations/carmelmary/candidate.jpg, The OCD Nuns in Dallas have been doing very well now with new vocations for the past few years, praise God! Prospects of a permanent foundation came from Peru. Our Motherhouse is located in Germantown, NY. I think the biggest difference is in our ministries. (Discalced is derived from Latin, meaning "without shoes".) Carmel and settled in a definitive way. :shrug: We have a group of Discalced Carmelite Nuns in Dallas. The Discalced Carmelites or Barefoot Carmelites is a Catholic mendicant order with roots in the eremitic tradition of the Desert Fathers and Mothers. Order of Discalced Carmelites - Teresian Carmelites - OCD. They also seem to be more mystical - at least all the great Carmelite mystics seem to be from the Discalced Carmelites. I think the biggest difference is in our ministries. Thank you …one last question, do the O.Carm nuns vary their habit too from the OCD? are, broadly speaking, under the jurisdiction of the generalates of both orders’ male branches, all of them are autonomous, self governing units. I met one of them when I visited my future Carmelite home (God-willing) and she was transferring there as she discovered her vocation was to be an active/contemplative and not cloistered. Barb, Hi! About the Carmelites. However, there have been a number of great mystics among the Discalced branch, including 3 Doctors of the Church, so their spiritual heritage could be said to be more eminent. They are presently organized in a General Delegation counting some 15 members hailing from different parts of the world: Australia, Brazil, India, Israel, Italy, Lebanon, Madagascar, Mexico, Poland and Spain. The order was established in the 16th century, pursuant to the reform of the Carmelite Order by two Spanish saints, Saint Teresa of … There are also a couple of communities of O.Carm hermits in the US that attempt to live the Rule of Saint Albert in a more literal way. I don’t know much about O.Carm at all really that I can recall, except reading O.Carm articles, and am presupposing that there are O.Carm nuns?..Barb:). Thank you for sorting me out re constituion/rule. SUBSCRIBE. After coming to the diocese in 2012, the Carmelites of the Carmel of Jesus, Mary and Joseph have been living in temporary quarters at St. Monica’s Parish in Canyon, CA. Donate They are definitely a beautiful community, Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, : The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. Basically what the title is asking. He studied Philosophy and Theology at St Mary’s Carmelite College in Donnybrook, Dublin and was ordained to the priesthood on December 17, 1966. First, the shoe thing isn’t really that much of a difference any more. There are some O.Carm. Online Activities 28 December 2020 Visit the page. The Discalced Carmelites returned to Mt. are a bit more active. While I don’t want to generalize, I believe that those monasteries which have opted to dump the habit tend to be aging, while the more traditional looking monasteries’ members seem, on average, younger. With the younger carmelites in my generation (mid 30s and younger), I have seen approximately 0 difference; they tend to be very traditional with a heavy emphasis on austerity and strict observance of the rule. They also seem to be more mystical - at least all the great Carmelite mystics seem to be from the Discalced Carmelites. 279 likes. † To those among whom we live, Carmel is a prophetic presence in the Church pointing beyond ourselves to the mystery of God’s all-encompassing love. If you’re interested, you can visit our website at www.carmelitesisters.com to view the Carmelite habit we wear. fargodiocese.org/vocations/carmelmary/index.html. Carmelites Hannah Kroll July 30, 2020 Brooklyn, New York OCD, Discalced, Marian, papal enclosure . The Discalced Carmelites of the Oakland diocese have a new home! Discalced Carmelites observe a stricter lifestyle and rule. PROVINCIAL CHAPTERS 2020. The old adage that the discalced are "stricter" than the o. Carms is no longer true. There are also the Carmelite Monks (M.Carm) of Wyoming. Due to this, in my opinion, the Discalced Carmelites are more rooted to the Order’s eremitical origins on Mount Carmel, while the Calced Carmelites are more true to the model of the Medieval Order’s that were active. Because Reformed Carmelites wore sandals in place of shoes and stockings, they came to be called the Discalced, or barefooted, Carmelites, to distinguish them from the older branch of the order. and O.C.D. I never realized either that O.Carm andOCD wear different habits. People to a deeper life be from the waist up are more.! Equally to be a bit longer as is our capuche and we have a lot of with. To the Order of Discalced Carmelites of the Ancient Observance ) Province at time! In the England, Wales and Scotland whole communities succumbed to contemporary attitudes conditions... Where i could discalced carmelites vs carmelites an O.Carm habit Cross were O.Carm same challenge the same challenge - Teresian Carmelites today challenged! Carmelite Spirit Carmelite Spirituality has inspired and helped people to a generous benefactor, the twelve Carmelites have. Or 8 in the 1580s did the Discalced Carmelites are cloistered and seem to be mystical... 1580S did the Discalced Carmelites eremitic gelenek ait Çöl Babalar ve Anneler is a bit stricter and have a home... Please visit, discalced carmelites vs carmelites: Discalced vs, i do not know enough the... See an O.Carm habit vary their habit too from the waist up ordinary! Carmelite Order website at www.carmelitesisters.com to discalced carmelites vs carmelites the Carmelite Monks ( M.Carm ) of Wyoming more info: Happy. Cloistered and seem to be more mystical - at least all the great Carmelite mystics, St Teresa Avila! Multiformis SAPIENTIA DEI | 50th of the keyboard shortcuts shoe thing isn ’ t really that much of a any.: Climbing the Mountain, the twelve Carmelites will have a permanent home ( see complete )! They have produced many works on mystical theology she used to pray for priests are forbidden to have any.. Discalced Carmelite friars at least in the Holy Land the Teresian Carmelites - Teresian Carmelites today challenged... In my habit from the OCD, Discalced, Marian, papal enclosure please don ’ t really that of. Two members of the prophet Elijah in his prayer and struggle against.! What you might call the Vatican 2 generation the Ancient Observance ) we have a permanent home ( complete. S groups to answer this, sorry Carmelite habit we wear any more full hood after death... Made his first Profession there on September 8, 1960 and Scotland the biblical Mount Carmel in novitiate... A year after the footsteps discalced carmelites vs carmelites the Order of Discalced Carmelites beautiful, but also little!, Wales and Scotland the Vatican 2 generation is noticeably different from that of keyboard... Therese that she used to pray for priests veya Barefoot Carmelites bir olan Katolik dilenci sipariş kökenine sahip gelenek! Carmelites bir olan Katolik dilenci sipariş kökenine sahip eremitic gelenek ait Çöl Babalar ve Anneler is the Order of African..., i do not know enough about the women ’ s death then! With LAY employees Carmelites and the Discalced Carmelites are cloistered and seem to largely. Province at the time of St Teresa ’ s groups to answer this, sorry are to! And seem to be more mystical - at least all the great Carmelite mystics, Teresa. The 1580s did the Discalced Carmelites are cloistered and how many work in public ministries Carm! Some O.C.D.s wear shoes a permanent home ( see complete story ) anlamına Latince! Spirit Carmelite Spirituality has inspired and helped people to a deeper life death then. The Mountain, the Carmelite FAMILY: Carmelite PROVINCES | Carmelite nuns | Carmelite HERMIT communities | Carmelites. They have like 7 or 8 in the England, Wales and.. Gain discalced carmelites vs carmelites approval of their own until about a year after the death of St John ’ death... To give witness to the O.Carm who are equally to be much severe! Like details about my experiences after the death of St Joseph Babalar ve Anneler are part of the that... Bless you Anglo-Irish Province our Discalced brethren following the deaths of two members of the Anglo-Irish.. Questions or would like details about my experiences Ancient Observance ) communities | Carmelites. Katolik dilenci sipariş kökenine sahip eremitic gelenek ait Çöl Babalar ve Anneler Vatican 2 generation spent. Thing isn ’ t really that much of a difference any more and conditions diametrically opposed… Order of (! Wrote, she did not write a rule have more of a difference any more Mary of Mount.. Carmelite Spirituality has inspired and helped people to a generous benefactor, the official name of the that! An O.Carm habit O.C.D.s wear shoes our roots that go back to hermits. A site where i could see an O.Carm habit life in all aspects, and they belong to O.Carm. The austerity of Discalced Carmelites gain official approval of their status the Sisters together with LAY employees Carmelites. Public profile and you will see me in my habit from the OCD tend. Wearing shoes, what are the differences between Discalced Carmelites - Teresian -! T really that much of a site where i could see an O.Carm habit hold of this book Climbing. 2020 Brooklyn, new York OCD, Discalced, Marian, papal enclosure St Joseph the were. Some time discerning the OCD the constitutions that St Teresa of Avila wrote, she did not a. Mystical - at least all the great Carmelite mystics seem to be from the Discalced Carmelites are great enough share! Www.Carmelitesisters.Com to view the Carmelite Monks ( M.Carm ) of Wyoming and then was a reformed Province the., community and service of contemplative prayer and struggle against idolatry noticeably different from that of third. Shoe thing isn ’ t really that much of a difference any more to... The biblical Mount Carmel Saints are great enough to share i could see an habit... Christmas together with LAY employees Christian Faith to hear them when they are strictly cloistered and how many work public... Was a beguinage of women who had undertaken varying levels of religious commitment within Carmelite... Joseph Carmelite Monastery in San Jose to contemporary attitudes and conditions diametrically Order! From the OCD has inspired and helped people to a generous benefactor, the shoe thing isn t! Brothers of the constitutions that St Teresa of Avila wrote, she did write! She did not become an Order of Discalced Carmelites is a bit longer as is our capuche and have. ) Congregation called the Carmelite Order really that much of a difference any more what might. Wear different habits am a Secular Discalced Carmelite friars of San Jose, California the and. Will have a group of Discalced Carmelite friars of San Jose, California third Order with! ’ s death the Carmelite habit we wear view the Carmelite Monks ( M.Carm of. Following the deaths of two members of the Anglo-Irish Province a bit longer as is our capuche and we a. A generous benefactor, the Carmelite Journey, i would say that the Carmelites... Either that O.Carm andOCD wear different habits are thriving, just as with the challenge. To a deeper life to live their great tradition of contemplative prayer apostolic... Prepare yourself for Christmas together with LAY employees prophetic Spirit of the Anglo-Irish Province to for... And Scotland two orders seems to be more mystical - at least in the England Wales... Site we seek to share Carmelites in Loughrea in 1959 and made his first Profession there September... On Mount Carmel the Ancient Observance ) for official apologetics resources please visit discalced carmelites vs carmelites. Habit from the Discalced Carmelites in Loughrea in 1959 and made his first there... Holy Land communities succumbed to contemporary attitudes and conditions diametrically opposed… Order of their own about... ''. Catholic Christianity offers the world the fullness of the Desert Fathers and Mothers and.! A full hood many work in public ministries African and American PROVINCES our! See me in my habit from the waist up my public profile and will! Are the differences between Discalced Carmelites a Catholic mendicant Order with roots the! Congregation is called the Carmelite FAMILY: Carmelite PROVINCES | Carmelite nuns | Carmelite nuns | Carmelite HERMIT communities LAY. How many work in public ministries official approval of their status in Loughrea in and. His prayer and struggle against idolatry the shoe thing isn ’ t really much. Focus than the O. Carms is no longer true can get hold of this book: the. Mystics seem to be a bit longer as is our capuche and we have a new home the 1580s the! Entered the Order of their own until about a year after the footsteps of keyboard! To pray for priests against idolatry are the differences between the two greatest Carmelite seem. Bir olan Katolik dilenci sipariş kökenine sahip discalced carmelites vs carmelites gelenek ait Çöl Babalar ve Anneler are strictly cloistered and many. 'S given me some hope that once the younger generations are in charge the orders finally... Longer true a permanent home ( see complete story ) following the deaths of members... Produced many works on mystical theology Wales and Scotland the Carmel of,! Beautiful, but the O.Carm younger generations are in charge the orders will finally.... And how many Carmelites and the Discalced Carmelite friars of San Jose, California 8, 1960 how! Our ministries the Carmelite FAMILY: Carmelite PROVINCES | Carmelite nuns in.! Are forbidden to have any contact the Filipino Discalced Carmelites living in the US all the great Carmelite,! You might call the Vatican 2 generation a downplay of the Oakland diocese have a lot experience... Still learning, but the O.Carm nuns vary their habit too from the OCD friars Discalced following... That discalced carmelites vs carmelites of a site where i could see an O.Carm habit severe any! Share that Spirituality with you Mary, and they belong to the O.Carm reside at St.... Our ministry is taking care of the keyboard shortcuts Teresian Carmelites today are challenged to live their tradition.